If you've ever lugged a heavy amp to a gig, you know the struggle is real. But what if there was a way to lighten your load without sacrificing the heart of your sound? Enter digital amp sims. In the ever-evolving world of live music, and the growing list of guitar pedals, the debate rages on: digital amp sims or traditional amps? Today, we're diving into the pros and cons of using digital amp sims for live performances and why, in my opinion, digital is the way to go.
Pros of Digital Amp Sims
Portability and Convenience:
Let's face it, carrying around a traditional amp can be a workout. Especially for those in the 4x12 cab club. Not only that, but they take up so much space in storage or in a trailer. Digital amp sims are lightweight and easy to transport, making them a dream for gigging musicians who are always loading in and loading out, each and every weekend. This point alone has converted many purists over to the convenience of a digital amp sim..
Versatility:
With digital amp sims, you have a world of tones and effects at your fingertips. Whether you're switching from a clean jazz tone to a heavy metal crunch, digital sims offer a range of sounds without the need for multiple amps. If you’re someone who wants to recreate every single tone live, digital is the only way to realistically pull that off (unless you’re Rev. Billy Gibbons).
Consistency:
One of the biggest challenges in live performances is maintaining sound quality across different venues. Digital amp sims provide consistent sound, ensuring your performance is what you want it to be every time. No more messing with physical mic’s and making sure it’s on the spot of the speaker you like, then leaving your tone up for interpretation by the sound guy. You’re able to give them exactly what they need, take the guess work out of it for them, and have that same sound each and every time you show up.
Integration with Modern Tech:
In today's digital age, integration is key. Digital amp sims easily connect with MIDI rigs and other digital setups, offering seamless performance enhancements. If you want to know more about what this looks like, I’ve made a few blog posts on automating your pedalboard and even using your laptop as an amp sim live if you want to dive deeper into those subjects.
Cons of Digital Amp Sims
Sound Authenticity:
This is the biggest argument I see from the purists out there. And I’d consider myself a purist as well, which might surprise you from reading some of this blog haha. I’m going to give this point to the purists however, digital sims might not replicate the warmth and feel of a tube amp. It's a common and fair critique in my opinion, but one that's becoming less of an issue as technology advances. I’ve been really impressed with some of the newer releases from ToneX and Neural DSP. And I think Fractal has done a great job with this for some time now as well, but it’s still not quite the same as playing a real analog amp, though I think this gap is starting to close more and more as the technology progresses.
Learning Curve:
Dialing in the perfect tone can be a challenge, especially for those new to digital gear. Another point to the purists here. Usability is certainly a learning curve. I will say this though, if you’ve ever tried to set up a pedal like the Strymon big box pedals (Timeline, BIgSky, Mobius), it’s really not all that different. So with a little patience and practice you can get comfortable with your amp sim.
Making Changes Live:
This point is kind of a piggyback off the last point, but it is a “your mileage may vary” situation as well. You may need to make adjustments to your presets or tones every so often, what sounds epic in one venue might get completely lost in the mix in another, so adjustments might need to be made. Depending on your comfort level and familiarity with your amp sim’s interface this could be a simple tweak or require some deep menu diving.
Why Digital Wins in a Live Environment
Adaptability:
Digital amp sims offer flexibility and adaptability in various live settings, from small clubs to large venues. In general, you can easily tweak your sound to suit the environment, whereas with a real amp, a lot of the time you’re at the mercy of wherever the stage hand stuck the microphone, typically there’s not going to be someone who’s back at the amp moving the mic a half an inch until you and the house engineer can agree on what’s the “right” sound. An amp sim actually takes that situation and throws it out the door completely. You get your tone right ahead of time, and the sound guy gets what you give him and it should already be where you want it to be.
Cost-Effectiveness:
While the initial investment might be significant, so is your dream amp. Still, the long-term savings on maintenance and versatility make digital sims a smart choice for any musician.
Future-Proofing:
Digital technology is constantly improving, with updates and new features keeping your gear current and your sound fresh. You’re also future proofing your preferences for tone. If you’re a Marshall purist for a few years; great. But then all of a sudden you’re wanting to try out having a Fender clean in your sound, digital makes that way cheaper and easier than having to buy an entirely new amp.
Conclusion
In the end, the choice between digital amp sims and traditional amps comes down to personal preference and needs. However, the benefits of digital amp sims for live use are hard to ignore. From portability and versatility to consistency and integration, digital amps offer a modern solution for today's musicians. So, why not give them a try and see how they can enhance your live performances?
And hey, if you're ready to take your live setup to the next level, I've got the perfect next step for you. Download my free Laptop Guitar Rig Guide to get started on building a pro-level rig that gives you clarity, control, and confidence on stage. Just click the link and grab your guide today! Let me know your thoughts in the comments below, and don't forget to share your experiences with digital amp sims!
Author
